If you haven’t heard of Hoosier Mama Pie Company, buckle up because your dessert game is about to level up. Nestled in the artsy and eclectic West Town neighborhood at 1618 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL 60622, this charming little pie shop has earned its stripes as a legendary Chicago staple — and for good reason. Whether you’re a sweet tooth crusader or a savory snack seeker, Hoosier Mama hits all the right notes.

Founded in 2009 by pastry genius Paula Haney, this pie shop is everything your grandma’s kitchen wishes it could be. But make no mistake — these pies aren’t stuck in the past. They’re reimagined classics, made from scratch with locally sourced ingredients and a whole lotta love.

🍰  What’s on the Menu? Pure Magic.

Hoosier Mama doesn’t play around with pie — this is serious business with a flaky crust. Their rotating menu changes daily, but here’s a taste of what you might find:

• Blueberry Sour Cream Pie – tart meets sweet in the most dreamy combo

• 🥥 Coconut Cream – fluffy, rich, and unapologetically indulgent

• Hoosier Sugar Cream – Indiana’s state pie, done better than anywhere else

• 🥓 Spinach, Mushroom & Bacon Quiche – for the savory souls

• 🍗 Chicken Pot Pie – warm, filling, and tastes like a hug

📌 Pro Tip: You can call ahead to reserve a whole pie (and trust me, you’ll want to).

🎨 The West Town Vibe

The shop sits on Chicago Avenue, right in the heart of West Town, one of the city’s most creative and colorful neighborhoods. Here’s what makes the area around Hoosier Mama so fun to explore:

• Intuit: The Center for Intuitive and Outsider Art – Just down the street and worth a stop.

• ☕ Big Shoulders Coffee – A cozy spot for a caffeine fix and some people-watching.

• Indie Boutiques & Vintage Stores – From handmade jewelry to rare vinyl, the shopping is a chef’s kiss.

• 🍻 Local Breweries – West Town is dotted with cool microbreweries. Grab a pint at Forbidden Root or On Tour Brewing Co. after your pie adventure.

🍒 Why It’s Worth the Hype

• Made-from-scratch pies — no shortcuts, no nonsense

• Quaint, cozy shop with big grandma’s kitchen energy

• Awesome local art scene just steps away

• Consistently ranked one of the best pie shops in America by the likes of Bon Appétit and Food Network

Honestly, it’s the kind of place you visit once, and then start planning your next trip back before you even finish your last bite.

🚗 Make It a Whole Day — With the Right Ride

Planning a pie pilgrimage to Hoosier Mama? You’re gonna want wheels to cruise through all that West Town has to offer. From museums and boutiques to breweries and bakeries, there’s too much goodness to fit into a cramped rideshare.

Book your ride with Chicago Adventure Rentals and explore the city your way. Whether you’re flying solo or rolling deep with your foodie crew, they’ve got the perfect car waiting for you. Prefer to chat it out? Give them a call at +1 872-296-8008 and get set up today!

Let the pie-fueled adventure begin! ✨